Welcome Friends!

A Catholic blog about faith, social issues, economics, culture, politics and poetry -- powered by Daily Mass & Rosary

If you like us, share us! Social media buttons are available at the end of each post.

Monday, September 30, 2013

A Child's Right to Mom and Dad: Why Kids of Gays Oppose Gay Adoption

by Susan Fox

When I was living in the Alps in Grenoble, France, in 1974, a group of school children – following their adult teacher -- skied off a cliff and died.

So go the lemmings behind the American Psychological Association and similar organizations around the world, which say that same-sex couples can raise mentally healthy children equally as well as opposite-sex attracted married couples.

“The research shows that same-sex couples are similar to heterosexual couples in essential ways and that they are as likely as opposite-sex couples to raise mentally healthy, well-adjusted children,” the APA said in a brief challenging the California Marriage Protection Act, Proposition 8, which was overturned in the U.S. Supreme Court June 26, 2013.  

The Supreme Court overturned the marriage act  -- passed by a majority of California voters to uphold marriage between one man and one woman -- but it did not impose gay marriage on the entire U.S. population. Nevertheless, the court hinted that they might do so in the future – just as they did with abortion in 1973 -- if the right case was brought before them. Wink. Wink. It's coming soon Nationwide. Cases are winding their way up to the Supreme Court and 19 states have legal same-sex marriage.


Gay “marriage” -- right or wrong -- is a critical issue for our time because marriage always comes with the right to “have”
children. I say “have” and not “bear” because for obviously reasons, gay couples cannot “bear” children.  Nature has not given them this ability.

So should they be allowed to marry and “obtain” children through in-vitro fertilization, surrogate mothers, sperm donors, adoption or inherit them as often happens when a divorcee moves in with a same-sex partner?

Increasingly, it is becoming more difficult to hold the opinion that gays should not be allowed to raise children. Witness what happened to Barilla Pasta when Chairman Guido Barilla said that children should be raised by a mother and a father. Now he is busy apologizing to the gay community while his pasta is boycotted.

Yet the people who are most outspoken against gay marriage and gays raising children are the very children the gays raised.  “I have heard of the supposed ‘consensus’ on the soundness of same-sex parenting from pediatricians and psychologists, but that consensus is frankly bogus” bi-sexual Robert O. Lopez told Life Site News.


Lopez – raised by two lesbians – says same-sex parenting is child abuse, nothing more, nothing less. “I don’t have a silver bullet for suddenly making low-information Americans aware that all the same-sex parenting propaganda is really a cover for systematic abuse (of children). My hunch, however, is that it might be time simply to drop all the masks, and just state the uncensored truth. If you think child abuse is wrong, then say so.”

“I am not saying that same-sex parents are automatically guilty of any kind of physical, sexual, or emotional abuse to the children they raise,” he clarified, but “even the most heroic mother in the world can’t father. So to intentionally deprive any child of her mother or father, except in cases like divorce or the death of a parent, is itself a form of abuse.”

Even gay parents are beginning to question the value of same-sex families. Stay-at-home gay father Frank Ligtvoet wrote a very courageous piece June 22, 2013 in the New York Times admitting that his seven-year-old daughter experiences both love and alienation when she calls him “mother,” using her pretend voice. “She can role-play the mother-daughter relationship, but she cannot use her real voice, nor have the real thing,” he said, explaining that he can fill their home “with nannies, sisters, grandmothers and female friends, but no mothers.”


Dawn Stefanowicz certainly has done all she can to raise awareness of the danger of same sex marriage and adoption. Her website, http://www.dawnstefanowicz.org is a haven for children of same-sex families, a place where they can get recovery information and tell their tragic stories.

Dawn Stefanowicz's book "Out from Under" is available at Amazon.com as well as www.dawnstefanowicz.org

Stefanowicz was raised by a gay father, his succession of lovers (all dead from AIDs or suicide) and a diabetic and passive mother. In Dawn’s book,  “Out From Under,” she outlines her abuse at home, how her father dressed her immodestly and used her as bait for other gays, how she was afraid to bring boyfriends home because her father would hit on them, and the confusion she suffered about her own feminine identity because her father did not value the women in his life.

She and her two brothers were subjected to incredible neglect and degradation from birth. She remembers the time that her father toyed with the idea of killing her or one of her brothers to cash in on his new insurance policy, having to clean up feces and sperm on the family room couch, never having a coat to wear in the winter, but the worse suffering for her seems to have been the emotional isolation she felt from her father, who was in her life, but unable to emotionally connect.

“What makes it so hard for a girl to grow up with a gay father is that she never gets to see him loving or honoring or protecting the women in his life.” Dawn said in her book’s conclusion. “Before therapy, being a woman was like acting out a role for me, like being a person who just happened to live in a female body.”

“Now I understand … that being a woman is part of who I am.” But the story of how she reached that point is one of the worst I’ve ever read. It’s not for weak stomachs, but I highly recommend the book.


So what happened? How did we get to this impasse? The American Psychological Association used to identify homosexuality as a mental illness, and certainly never advocated gay adoption. But gays were declared no longer sick in the late ‘70s under the leadership of APA president Dr. Nicholas Cummings. “I made the resolution that being gay
was not a mental illness, that it was characterological,” he said, that is, it is related to personality and character.  But it is “absurd” to say homosexuals cannot change, he added. He has helped no less that 2,400 homosexuals reorient during his 20-year practice in San Francisco.

At the time he removed the designation of mental illness from the APA he had hoped that the group would approve a resolution to continue unbiased open research on homosexuality that would demonstrate whatever the research would demonstrate.

But that never happened. Cummings says, instead, that the APA was hijacked by the gay movement, and no scientific research was done to understand the lifestyle and its implications for families. So now all that the APA has is the simple belief that homosexual relationships are normal with nothing to back it up. No science, nothing.

Yet the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco declared, “Children raised by gay or lesbian parents are as likely as children raised by heterosexual parents to be healthy, successful, and well-adjusted. The research supporting this conclusion is accepted beyond serious debate in the field of developmental psychology.”

Not so quick! The academic studies on same-sex parenting purporting to show "no differences" are “subject to severe constraints arising from limited data" and a lack of "replicable experiments," according to two political scientists, Leon Kass and Harvey Mansfield, who also filed a brief with the Supreme Court in the Prop 8 case. Numerous other sources confirmed this. It has been very difficult getting a statistically valid study because there are few gay-led families, and these generally are highly unstable.

REGNERUS: Finally, a study with a statistically significant population of gays

A new study conducted by sociologist Mark Regnerus of the University of Texas, Austin, is getting very positive attention in this discussion because it directly compares married opposite-sex families with same-sex couples raising children, and it uses a statistically significant study population, unlike previous studies, which supposedly settled the matter.

But the results of the new study are alarming. Children of gay unions are 10 times more likely to have been “touched” by a parent or adult caregiver, and 4 times more likely to have been raped.  They are also more likely to have attachment disorders related to the ability to depend on others. This is what Dawn was talking about in her relationship with her father. It was very hard for her to trust men. 

Imagine a young girl so insecure about her father’s responsibility that she hesitated to go to the end of a weak pier with him to take a picture.

And indeed, after he had the camera shot of his "make-me-look-good" daughter -- even though he knew his 9-year-old daughter was afraid in that location -- he turned around suddenly and abandoned her at the end of the pier.

Regnerus’ study found that children of homosexual parents

1)    are much more likely to have received welfare
2)   have lower educational attainment
3)   report less safety and security in their family of origin
4)   report more ongoing “negative impact” from their family of origin
5)   are more likely to suffer from depression
6)   have been arrested more often
7)   if they are female, have had more sexual partners – both male and female.

It has been claimed that children of homosexual parents are no more likely to be gay than children of heterosexual parents, but the Regnerus study proves that is not true. Children of homosexual fathers are nearly 3 times as likely, and children of lesbian mothers are 4 times as likely to identify themselves as something other than heterosexual.



That makes sense because a number of researchers have pointed out that homosexual adults are more likely to report having been victims of child sexual abuse. And this study shows that being raised in a gay home means you are more likely to be sexually abused.

Unfortunately, these statistics were replicated in Dawn’s life. Her father told her his father had sodomized him at least 100 times before he ran away at age 15. His father and older brothers also repeatedly raped his sister, who was handicapped because of the chronic abuse. One of Dawn’s brothers experimented briefly with a gay relationship in high school (the boyfriend she brought home) and then the brother brought a 14-year-old girl home, and proceeded to have noisy relations with her for several days as a way of telling his father he wouldn’t be gay.

And in the accounts I read, children of gays were very confused about how to act like a “woman” or act like a “man.”  Lopez complained that in high school his mannerisms were female, and he didn’t know how to change them.

Another child of a homosexual father, Suzanne Cook, says that after she and her brother moved in with her gay Dad after a divorce, her father's partner molested her brother for the next several years. "I had to deal with keeping my brother safe," Cook says. "I had to put on the role of a parent as a little kid. I felt the whole world on my shoulders."

But she herself was victimized because she was confused about her sexuality and thought the only way to avoid being “gay” was to offer sex to men. As a result her life included adultery, group sex and an abortion. She now strongly supports a ban on gay adoptions.


Cook feels that children of gays often avoid criticizing their parents in research projects. It is  taboo for a child in this situation to tell what is actually going on in the home, so research results tend to be abnormally rosy.

Dawn Stefanowicz added, “You’re terrified. Absolutely terrified. Children who open up these family secrets are dependent on parents for everything. You carry the burden that you have to keep secrets. You learn to put on an image publicly of the happy family that is not reality. With same-sex legislation, children are further silenced. They believe there is no safe adult they can go to.”

Lopez, who also does not support gay adoptions, said, “The richest and most successful same-sex couple still cannot provide a child something that the poorest and most struggling spouses can provide: a mom and a dad.”   
But that reality seems unjust to gay couples that want to have children. “Having spent forty years immersed in the gay community, I have seen how that reality triggers anger and vicious recrimination from same-sex couples, who are often tempted to bad-mouth so-called “dysfunctional” or “trashy” straight couples in order to say, “We deserve to have kids more than they do!” Lopez said.


If my Father is a "donor" or my Mother is an "incubator," what does that make me?

“It’s disturbingly classist and elitist for gay men to think they can love their children unreservedly after treating their surrogate mother like an incubator, or for lesbians to think they can love their children unconditionally after treating their sperm-donor father like a tube of toothpaste,” he wrote in a comment in LifeSite News  on June 3, 2013.
Yes, from a Christian perspective that is the whole problem with this debate. Human beings are made in the image and likeness of God. They have dignity and rights even from conception. But when you deliberately make a baby using a father “donor” or an incubator (surrogate) mother, you do not see the opposite sex parent as having dignity and worth as a human being. The child of that unnatural union becomes not a person, but a commodity. In the case of Dawn’s father, he kept a wife and children as a means of hiding his addiction to gay sex. In many lesbian relationships the child becomes a “trophy,” demonstrating “Hey, we’re just like everybody else.”
And that brings me to a heterosexual woman I met in San Francisco many years ago. She was a financial planner and I was a news reporter sitting together at lunch. She told me that she shared a home with a woman named “Mary.” She said they were true roommates not lovers, and chose to buy a house together because the cost of housing was too high for one person’s income.
She said she’d never found a man she wanted to marry, but she wanted children, so she had gone to a sperm bank and had her daughter 10 years before. Unfortunately, her daughter was not happy with that arrangement and desperately wanted to know who was her father? This woman told her daughter that she went to a store and got some “stuff” and conceived her, but the little girl would not accept that. So when the little girl went to school she told everyone there, “Other people have Moms and Dads, but I have a Mom and a Mary.”


My father died when I was four, and I was raised in a loving home by a chaste mother, who tried to be both father and mother to me. Because she modeled the feminine virtues and she was opposite-sex oriented, I had no confusion about how to be a woman. But the lack of father in the home did harm me because for much of my life I was afraid of men. I was  afraid of their voices. I have an elderly cousin who is very ill right now, and he was like a surrogate father to me. His children and I were raised as brothers and sisters. But he had a deep male voice and as a young girl I was always a little afraid of him.
One day one of us kids tracked mud in the house, and he demanded we all show our shoes. His children were all shocked and so was I when he wanted to see the bottom of my shoes because I always was the well-behaved one. I remember my fear of the male father figure was quite intense in that moment, but luckily I didn’t have any mud so my reputation remained intact!
Recently, as my dear cousin lies in the nursing home, I told him he was like a father to me when I was growing up, and his wife, my cousin, said I made him very happy. But it took – what? – 50 years for me to tell him! Just because I was raised without a father?
After hearing about Dawn Stefanowicz, Blog Writer Wintery Knight raised these questions:  “Have you ever considered what effect it has on a child that they have to grow up without
their mother or their father? Is that something that we should be promoting so that there is more of it? It’s a sad thing to tell adults that they cannot do whatever they want, but it’s a sadder thing to harm children just so that adults can do whatever they want. We need to choose to be careful not to harm children by making poor decisions.”
Amen to that.

Since this post was published, two books came out outlining the same facts as this piece. One is "Jephthah's Daughters: Innocent Casualties in the War for Family Equality" edited by Robert Lopez and Rivka Edelman and "Making Gay Okay: How Rationalizing Homosexual Behavior Is Changing Everything" by Robert R. Reilly

You can read about these books here:

"Gay Parenting" Children Raised by Unchaste Adults Lead Difficult Lives" 

Same Sex "Marriage," Natural Law and the New Apocalypse


THE NEW EVANGELISTS: Bringing Christ, A Light to All People Who Experience Same Sex Attraction

Christian Bakery, closed by Oregon (In)Equality Law, Resists the Mark of the Beast

MEANWHILE IN RUSSIA by a Blogger who Experiences Same Sex Attraction

SEX and The Mystery of Gravy

My Sources on this topic:

Gay Parenting on Trial

Gay parents are more likely to raise gay kids

Growing Up with Two Moms: The Untold Children's View

New Study on Homosexual Parents Tops All Previous 

Court Shouldn't Rewrite Law on Gay Marriage

Former APA President Says Homosexuals Can Change

State Weeding Out Christian Beliefs

Same-sex parenting: child abuse?

Do social scientists get to have a "consensus" on our right to free speech? Why do they get to tell us whether we have a right to a mom and a dad?

The Misnomer of "Motherless" Parenting

Are gay relationships typically stable and monogamous?

The American Psychological Association on lesbian and gay parenting

A secular case against same-sex marriage

Comparing the Lifestyles of Homosexual Couples to Married Couples

The Commodification of Children and the Insensitivity of the Culture


  1. Are you for real? There is no formal peer reviewed papers on any of the false claims you have made. Do you know how many families have closet gay dads or closet gay wives? Most stay together for the children and split after the children are grown. I think you better start reading the literature about gay parenting before your next set of lies

  2. Dear Anonymous there are 14 sources on the story. Please read all of them before you make such allegations.

  3. this is insanity . My gay cousins son loves his father. My cousin has a job that he is supporting his child from a orphanage in Vietnam. He could not love him more then 2 straight parents. Your blogs sources are all biased and doesn't really base itself on real life children. There is no better father then my cousin. So really learn about real life and stop being so homophobic.

  4. Dear Anonymous,
    I truely believe that that gay father, Frank Ligtvoet, whom I quote from the New York Times piece, has nothing but the deepest love in his heart for his daughter. You can tell it by his comments. But love is not really the issue. The issue is can his daughter learn to be a woman? Can she garner a respect for herself as a woman when he has -- by his lifestyle -- no respect for women. With the best of the intentions he can raise a very disturbed child. I don't think --as is happening in Russia-- that children of gays should necessarily be removed from their homes. But I don't think they should be placed there in the first place because it is unfair to the child. That is no statement against someone living that lifestyle. I make no judgements on any individual. I'm still trying to puzzle out why lesbian households get worse marks than gay male households in the Regnerus study? My prejudice is for female led households as I grew up in one! If you have any insight on this please explain.

    Re: the studies question. If you look at my sources at the bottom of the page, there is 59 studies done by the APA, and none of them used a large enough study sample to even meet the APA's standards, so all the research before Regnerus is bogus! He started with 18,000 families. He found 173 lesbian led families out of the 18,000 that met the criteria of being around for at least three years. and only about 73 gay male led families. The problem is that gay families like gay relationships are unstable. They don't last that long. That is further destabilizing for the children. Also I only picked a few stories of gay children, but you can go to the Dawn Stefanowicz web site, and she has numerous stories written by children of gays. I couldn't find any adults raised by gays who have had the courage to go on the internet, and tell us how wonderful it was growing up. Have you? Be happy to read them. God bless you. Your new friend, Susan Fox

  5. "The problem is that gay families like gay relationships are unstable. They don't last that long."

    Apparently you enjoy just making up shit.

  6. Dear Anonymous, No I am basing it on what I read. Read the sources at the bottom of the article. That is what they are talking about. The reason why previous research was bogus is because they can't find a large enough statistically important population of relatively stable gay families. The Regnerus study interviewed 18,000 families found less than 250 gay families with a three year track record. God bless you. Susan Fox

  7. I am not questioning the value of same-sex families at all. Just read the whole piece. It is always annoying (for me) and dishonest (of you) to quote just for your own argument's sake. I shiver.

    Frank Ligtvoet, Brooklyn
    Write of The misnomer of Motherless Parenting

  8. Dear Frank, How lovely to hear from you. I didn't think you were against same sex families as you form one. I simply thought your insights were quite astute. You raised an important question. God bless you. Susan Fox

  9. Susan,

    I have noticed that there are talented writers like yourself who have a strong Catholic faith and who pour themselves into controversial issues such as same sex marriage. Unlike unbiased writers, their articles never give both sides of the story and they cherry pick anecdotal stories that support their opinions which are based on their religious beliefs and the dictates of their religious leaders.

  10. Dear Bill S., I doubt this is you posting as all the other posts on this comment section are fake (except mine). But assuming it is. I didn't cherry pick. I gave the other side ample opportunity to show me one adult story where he or she was raised by gays and had a happy experience. There are none. Or they would have produced them. They produced testimonials from children and gay adults raising children, but Dawn Stefanowicz in her book said both of her parents had to die before she could tell the truth. When they were alive, she testified and acted as if they were one big happy family. Read her book. It is a horror story. Any child in that situation would be afraid to say anything against their parents. Even the bi-sexual raised by lesbians, Robert Lopez, who is an adult with a PhD., still can't bring himself to say anything against his mother. He makes excuses for her behavior. It's true I only told a few of the stories of children raised by gays, there were many many more stories from adults who had been raised by gays, and they were all just as bad. Some of them so bad I couldn't publish them. What I did with this story is take members of the gay community and children raised by one or both gay parents, and let them explain the problem with gay adoption. I let their own community tell them the truth. I didn't use Pope Benedict or the Bible. I let gays and children of gays tell their story. You simply can't accept it. There are tons of other stories, none of them good, but if you would like a sidebar with the other bad stories, I can produce it. God bless you. Susan Fox

  11. Oct 13, 2015, Dear Anonymous, I'm sorry I couldn't publish your rude comments. The homosexual takeover of the APA is very well established. At least two books came out after this was written documenting the same facts in this piece. One is Jephthah's Daughters: Innocent Casualties in the War for Family Equality. I wrote about the book here: Same Sex Marriage, Natural Law and the New Apocalypse http://christsfaithfulwitness.blogspot.com/2015/04/same-sex-marriage-and-new-apocalypse.html#.Vh2_A7T0iIk and here "Gay Parenting:" Children Raised by Unchaste Adults Lead Difficult Lives http://christsfaithfulwitness.blogspot.com/2015/07/the-poison-of-gay-parenting-children.html#.Vh2_cbT0iIk

    The other excellent book on this matter is "Making Gay Okay" by Robert R. Reilly. It outlines the same facts in more detail. Both books were published after this piece was written. God bless you. Susan Fox www.christsfaithfulwitness.com

    P.S. A 12-year commitment to a sinful behavior is not a stable relationship.